Most people only think about their locks when something goes wrong – a key snaps off, a deadbolt stops turning, or they’re standing on the porch at 11 p.m. with the door shut behind them. A little planning beats that scramble. This guide covers what Salt Lake City homeowners actually need to know about their locks, when to call a professional, and how to avoid paying for work you don’t need.
Rekey vs. Replace: Know the Difference
These two get confused constantly, and the mix-up can cost you money. Rekeying changes the internal pins of a lock so the old key no longer works and a new key does. The lock body stays on your door. Replacing means swapping out the entire hardware.
Rekeying is the right move in a few common situations:
- You just bought a house and have no idea how many copies of the key are floating around.
- A roommate, tenant, or contractor had a key and moved on.
- You want several doors to open with one key but your locks don’t match.
Replace the hardware when the lock is physically worn, damaged, or outdated – a deadbolt that wobbles, a knob that sticks even after cleaning, or old hardware that doesn’t meet a decent security grade. If you have four or five exterior doors, rekeying all of them to a single key is usually far cheaper than buying new locks for each.

What Good Residential Hardware Looks Like
Not all deadbolts are equal. Look for locks graded by the ANSI/BHMA standard – Grade 1 is the strongest and built for heavy use, Grade 2 is solid for most homes, and Grade 3 is the bare minimum. For an exterior door, aim for Grade 1 or 2.
The lock itself is only half the story. A deadbolt is only as strong as the strike plate and the screws holding it. Swap the short screws that come in the box for three-inch screws that reach the wall framing behind the door jamb. That single change does more to resist a kick-in than almost any upgrade to the lock cylinder. A locksmith will do this as part of a proper installation, but it’s worth checking.
Smart Locks
Keypad and app-controlled locks are genuinely useful if you hate carrying keys or want to give access codes to a dog walker or house cleaner. Two things to check before you buy: whether it fits your existing door prep without new holes, and whether it has a physical key backup. Batteries die, and you don’t want to be locked out of your own smart lock.
Handling a Lockout Without Making It Worse
If you’re locked out, resist the urge to force it. Prying a door or jamming a card into the latch often damages the frame or the lock, turning a simple opening into a hardware replacement. Before you call anyone:
- Check every other door and any ground-floor windows.
- See if a trusted neighbor or family member has a spare.
- If you rent, call your landlord or property manager first – they may be obligated to let you in at no cost.
When none of that works, a professional can almost always open a standard residential lock without damaging it. A good locksmith opens before they drill, and drilling is a last resort for high-security or seized locks. If someone shows up and wants to drill a basic deadbolt immediately, that’s a red flag.

Hiring a Locksmith You Can Trust
The locksmith trade attracts its share of bait-and-switch operators who advertise a low fee, then pile on charges once they’re at your door. Protect yourself:
- Get a real quote before they come out. Describe the job – lock type, door type, what happened – and ask for an estimate including the service call fee.
- Look for a physical address and a local phone number. A company with a storefront is accountable in a way a call-center dispatch isn’t.
- Ask for ID on arrival. A legitimate technician won’t be offended.
- Confirm the price in writing or by text before work begins.
For routine jobs like rekeying or a new deadbolt, you have time to compare. For a middle-of-the-night lockout, keep the number of a company you’ve already vetted saved in your phone so you’re not picking blindly under pressure.
When to Call vs. Do It Yourself
Replacing a worn knob or deadbolt with the same model is a reasonable weekend project if you’re handy. Where it pays to bring in a pro: rekeying multiple locks to one key, fixing a door that won’t latch because the frame has shifted (common in older Salt Lake homes), installing a lock on a door with no existing bore, or anything involving your car or a commercial-grade system. A locksmith also carries the tools to repair rather than replace in cases where a DIYer would just buy new.
The Takeaway
Do three things this month: upgrade your exterior deadbolt strike plates to three-inch screws, rekey your locks if you’ve moved in within the past year or handed out keys you can’t account for, and save a vetted local locksmith’s number before you ever need it. Those steps cost little and spare you the worst version of a lock problem.